Wednesday, February 19, 2014
Whatever happened to Concern Worldwide's cash transfer programs?
Before GiveDirectly burst upon the scene, other charities operated cash transfer and voucher programs with less fanfare – and they still do so. GiveDirectly has in fact relied on reviews and evaluations of these earlier programs to promote its own valuable work. In a 2010 research note, GiveDirectly stated: "Reviewing cash transfer projects run by Concern Worldwide and Oxfam following flooding in Western Zambia, Concern Worldwide (2007) found that less than 0.5% of the transfers were spent on 'unproductive' uses (including alcohol and tobacco)."
I began contributing to Concern Worldwide because I read about its cash transfer and voucher programs. Apparently these programs continue; a page on Concern Worldwide's website is devoted to them: https://www.concern.net/category/free-tagging/cash-transfer. However, Concern Worldwide does not appear to be promoting these cash transfer programs: its home page does not mention them, and I could not even reach its page on cash transfers through links on its home page (I found the page on cash transfers through Google).
Possibly Concern Worldwide's reticence about its cash transfer programs reflects an old-fashioned assumption that contributors to international charities do not favor cash transfers. I would have thought, and hoped, that Concern Worldwide would be more willing to expand and promote its own cash transfer programs now that GiveDirectly has made such programs by charities (dare I say it) sexy. I actually think the structure of Concern Worldwide's programs is superior to that of GiveDirectly's programs: As I have argued, GiveDirectly's standard grant of $1,000 per family is too large.
Saturday, February 1, 2014
There is something off-putting about the Deworm the World/Evidence Action websites
Having discovered the charity Deworm the World on the GiveWell website, I went to the Deworm the World website, intending to contribute. There I saw this off-putting statement in large type at the top of the website, preceding any description of the charity's program or the problem it is meant to address:
I also found Evidence Action's own website a little off-putting, though I can't put my finger on exactly why.
Nevertheless, I have sent them a check.
Evidence
Action is now responsible for the management, strategic
direction and growth of Deworm the World.
Programs of the Deworm the World Initiative at Evidence Action are implemented
in partnership with Action Foundation for Social Services in India and Innovations for Poverty Action in Kenya . Learn more about Evidence Action.
This is like something you would see during the opening credits of a movie, or maybe at an athletic event where sponsors are elbowing each other to put their names front and center. The charity's mission and program kind of take a back seat to brand promotion.
I also found Evidence Action's own website a little off-putting, though I can't put my finger on exactly why.
Nevertheless, I have sent them a check.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)